Are all firewalls created equal?
In many successful companies
today, information security is becoming a high priority. One of the hot topics
and a device that everyone seems to associate as the single most important
element in securing the environment is the firewall. The firewall is that magic
box that separates your production systems from the anonymous outside world of
the Internet. It is true that the firewall can be considered the cornerstone of
a secured environment. However, simply having any firewall in place certainly
does not constitute a secured environment.
First, let’s discuss the broad
term “firewall” itself. There are presently a myriad of devices today being
described as firewalls. Simply stated, you can classify firewalls in three
categories:
Basic Filtering / Proxy
Devices: These devices provide the most basic and cost-effective
solutions for businesses or home users with a very limited security budget.
They should only be used in situations where there is only outbound traffic and
very limited or no traffic inbound to the production network. This is because
these devices do little or nothing to monitor the traffic that does pass through
them.
Small-office Firewalls:
These devices are the fastest growing segment of the firewall market. Many
companies are producing these new small-office or midrange firewall devices.
The main emphasis here is a firewall device that businesses can afford, while
achieving a higher level of protection when allowing some traffic to pass into
the production environment. They have some form of built-in reporting and some
even have a form of alerting for various security events. Unfortunately, these
devices offer very little in terms of additional monitoring (inspection) of the
traffic that is allowed to pass through them and therefore are still vulnerable
to several popular types of attacks.
Enterprise Firewalls:
Enterprise firewalls are designed with large-business needs in mind. They offer
extensive management and reporting capabilities, as well as incorporate more
sophisticated inspection of both outbound and inbound traffic. Even when
traffic is allowed to pass through the firewall and into the production
environment the firewall inspects the contents of each communication and ensures
the traffic is what it appears to be. This additional inspection provides a
very significant advantage over the small-office firewall and can even prevent
many common security threats.
One misconception today is that
most firewalls are created equal and many IT managers often do not know about or
understand the differences between small-office and enterprise firewall
technologies. It is this misconception that can create unknown risks for
companies who believe their firewall is sufficient. Hackers can take advantage
of the lack of inspection by small-office firewalls and in some cases circumvent
the firewall all together by imbedding malicious code within what appears to be
normal network traffic. Several vendors like Checkpoint, which currently has
about a 65% market share, are now incorporating their inspection technology into
home and remote/small office firewalls at very competitive prices.
One of the most serious problems
today with firewall implementations is the fact that a very high percentage of
firewalls are actually improperly configured. These issues range from poor use
of configuration standards to not blocking unnecessary traffic that can and do
lead to actual intrusions. Poor setup and configuration, as well as little or
no monitoring resources from within the technology group are some of the most
common causes for denial of service attacks and successful intrusion attempts.
Even with a properly configured
and monitored firewall device that provides inspection technology, IT managers
and alike have to realize that even then their security posture may be suspect.
If the servers that are accessed through the firewall by Internet users are not
administered properly with current security fixes and patches, the entire
environment is still vulnerable. Because of the difficulty in staying current
with all of the new security updates to web, email, database, and other servers
many companies need to look to Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) to identify
when intruders are trying to take advantage of server vulnerabilities. IDS
technology can identify many types of malicious activity that take advantage of
security flaws and reduce the risks of not having the latest patches applied.
As you can see, simply having
some kind of firewall device in place definitely does not constitute a secured
environment. All companies should be consulting with either internal or outside
security experts about the risks of their firewall selection and administration,
perform regularly scheduled penetration testing audits, and/or consider Managed
Security Service Providers (MSSP) before they really feel a sense of confidence
with their security protection.
|